The Fifth Seal – Souls Under the Altar: The Slain Eunuchs

Revelation 6:9-11 (NASB): “When He opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of those who had been slain because of the word of God and the testimony they had maintained; and they cried out with a loud voice, saying, ‘How long, O Lord, holy and true, will You refrain from judging and avenging our blood on those who dwell on the earth?’"

​​

The fifth seal reveals no distant catastrophe. There are no riders of conquest, war, famine, or death advancing across the earth. Instead, it uncovers something far more intimate—and far more profane.

​

The slain are not found on battlefields or in the aftermath of invasion, but beneath the altar of worship itself.

​

Their deaths did not occur at the hands of the godless, but under the authority of the devout—those who believed they were defending truth, honouring God, and preserving righteousness. Scripture, misdirected by certainty and severed from love, became a blade rather than a balm.

The blood of the faithful stains the very place meant for communion with God.

​

This seal indicts a pattern as old as religion itself: when love is detached from righteousness, devotion does not weaken—it becomes lethal.

​

 

THE MEASURE THAT NEVER CHANGES

 

Scripture’s moral core is neither ambiguous nor negotiable. It has never shifted with culture, tradition, or power.

​

It is love.

​

Not vague affection, not reluctant tolerance, not fleeting emotional approval—but the unrelenting demand that exposes every counterfeit righteousness.

​

If I speak in the tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I am a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal.

​If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but have not love, I am nothing.

​If I surrender my body to the flames, but have not love, I gain nothing.

(1 Corinthians 13:1–3)

​​​

Love is patient and kind; it does not envy or boast; it is not arrogant or rude. It does not insist on its own way; it is not irritable or resentful; it does not rejoice at wrongdoing, but rejoices with the truth. Love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.

​Love never ends.

(1 Corinthians 13:4–8)

​

This is not poetry to soothe.

This is the blade Scripture turns upon itself.

​

Any interpretation that breeds arrogance, resentment, or delight in another’s pain stands already condemned. Any orthodoxy that dishonours, excludes, or wounds has already forsaken its source—no matter how loudly it quotes the text.

​

Love alone fulfils the law (Romans 13:8–10).

​Mercy alone triumphs over judgment (James 2:13).

 

Everything else is noise.

​

​

THE PATTERN: CERTAINTY WITHOUT LOVE

 

History does not merely illustrate this failure.

It weeps with it.

​

Generation after generation, Scripture is seized with unyielding confidence and forged into a weapon against those God calls neighbour.

​

Each era swears it guards divine truth.

Each era anoints its own interpretation as eternal.

Each era insists it has finally understood God rightly.

​

And each era, without exception, adds more blood beneath the altar.

 

The deception is never in the words of Scripture.

It is in the human heart that dares to wield them without trembling.

​

​

SLAVERY: REGULATION MISTAKEN FOR SANCTION

 

Scripture regulates slavery. It does not invent it, yet it does not uproot it with the thunder later conscience demanded.

 

For centuries, this silence was proclaimed as divine approval. Churches built doctrines of ownership upon it. Human beings were bought, sold, broken, and bred under the banner of biblical fidelity.

 

Those who profited most declared themselves God’s stewards.

 

Love was patient? No—whips were impatient.

​Love was kind? No—families were torn apart.

Love kept no record of wrongs? No—every scar was catalogued.

​

History did not amend Scripture.

It wept until the reading broke.

​

​

WOMEN: MYTH HARDENED INTO CHAINS

 

The story of Eve became law. Childbirth pain, once allegory, was preached as eternal punishment. Mutual submission was stripped of reciprocity and recast as silence. Half of humanity was sentenced by myth mistaken for mandate, and religious authority enforced it with absolute certainty, insisting this was God’s protective order.

​

As with slavery, what began as cultural regulation hardened into divine mandate—and mandate, once embodied, always demands compliance.

Love was not kind. Love did not guard. Love did not hope. Love did not preserve.

The chains were not iron—they were verses, recited with authority, bearing blood beneath the altar.

​

​

GALILEO: TRUTH SACRIFICED TO CERTAINTY

The heavens themselves declared God’s glory, yet human certainty refused to hear. Scripture, wielded not as illumination but as a shield for threatened authority, condemned inquiry. Galileo was not punished for error; he was punished for challenging that same "infallible" certainty.

​

Love, which rejoices in truth, was absent. Certainty, when threatened, became the prison for the quest of true knowledge. Centuries later, quiet apologies acknowledged what love had already exposed: truth cannot be crushed, only deferred.

​

​

MODERN ECHOES: FEAR IN THE LANGUAGE OF FAITH

The pattern endures—not always in doctrine, but in the proliferation of distrust and division. Flat-earth revivals, moon-landing hoaxes, vaccine conspiracies, and other anti-science crusades all flourish in soil fertilised by literalist certainty. When suspicion of expertise becomes a badge of faith, when complexity is condemned as corruption, and when being “right” matters more than being truthful, the altar claims new victims.

​

Scientific discovery is branded deception. Complexity is condemned as compromise. Knowledge puffs up; love builds up (1 Corinthians 8:1).

​​

When fear of being wrong outweighs love of truth, the altar receives more blood, and history’s pattern repeats itself—unbroken, unexamined, unrepentant.

​

​

THE PRESENT WOUND: SEXUAL DIFFERENCE

 

Every generation requires its offering.

 

Today, the blade falls heaviest on those whose sexual orientation or identity does not conform. Scripture is sharpened into weapon, context abandoned, fear sanctified as holiness.

 

Yet the pattern is old: as with slavery, as with women, as with Galileo, undue certainty masquerades as righteousness. The fruit is not patience or kindness, but shattered families, spiritual exile, and lives taught to despise themselves in God’s name.

​​

Scripture names such repeatedly targeted lives “eunuchs”—those whose bodies, desires, or callings fall outside sacred norms—yet whom God promises, through Isaiah and Jesus, a name better than sons and daughters, a place within the household that no one can ever rob away.

 

History stands as witness: every previous generation believed its condemnation was the final, righteous one.

Every single one was wrong.

​

​

FALSE RIGHTEOUSNESS: THE POSTURE GOD RESISTS

 

Only One can claim to speak truth with finality: God.

 

Every human voice that presumes otherwise stands already opposed.

 

Scripture itself warns: God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble (James 4:6). Who are you to judge another’s servant? (Romans 14:4). Live peaceably with all, as far as it depends on you (Romans 12:18), and show gentleness to everyone (Titus 3:2).

 

When certainty produces cruelty rather than care, exclusion rather than embrace, it has abandoned love’s allegiance.

 

If Love incarnate returned—speaking mercy to the marginalised, touching the untouchable, overturning tables of self-righteous commerce—He would not be welcomed.

He would be killed again, by hands quoting Scripture.

 

The pattern does not merely accuse.

It grieves.

​

​

LOVE’S FINAL VERDICT

 

Scripture has never pointed elsewhere.

 

Love God with all your heart.

Love your neighbour as yourself.

 

No interpretation that violates this love can claim to speak for its Author.

 

The fifth seal is not content with diagnosis.

It demands reckoning.

 

Read humbly.

Read aware of context.

Read suspicious of any certainty that demands harm.

 

The annexes that follow are not additions; they are recovery—of what fear buried, what pride obscured, what love always intended.

 

History has judged the misuse.

Love now judges the certainty.

 

The altar waits.

And the cry continues:

 

How long?